| ID |
First Name |
Last Name |
Comments | Location |
| 101 |
Hannah | Marsh |
This is serious - I do not want this happening to another team (except maybe Liverpool or Man U!) | Lincoln |
| 102 |
Hayleigh | Knibbs |
An absolute disgrace. | Cumbria |
| 103 |
stuart | mitchell |
if i did not know better I would say he had a bet on Liverpool to win that game, the worst display from a ref I have seen in my Lifetime. | Milton Keynes |
| 104 |
steffan | roberts |
Clattenburg was a disgrace to refereeing in this game. he somehow failed to give to clear penalties to everton and failed to send kyut of for a two footed tackle. disgrace to the game | llanfairfechan |
| 105 |
Marty | McKeown |
clattenburg brought out the yellow then gerrard told him to show red and he did - disgrace. The lescott is held back by finnan - no penalty - fuckin disgrace! Then Kuyt goes in wrecklesly and yellow! then in last minute lescott brought down,no pen,cheat | Belfast |
| 106 |
david | pilling |
i think there should be an investigation into his bank accounts to see just how much he got paid. Everton should stand up and fight against the most corrupt officiating ever in sport | elgin |
| 107 |
Neill | Taylor |
The facts remain that the referee unduly influenced the game. | Liverpool |
| 108 |
A M | Bonwick |
| Bedford |
| 109 |
john | foulkes |
| runcorn cheshire |
| 110 |
Adam | Flynn |
I think MR Clattenburg should be ashamed of his performance yesterday. Absolutely Disgraceful. The most unprofessional and incompetant refereeing I have ever witnessed during a football match. | Merseyside |
| 111 |
jason | wilson |
The referee was an absolute joke tbh. I'm a Liverpool fan but some of the decisions he give against Everton were unbelievable. with this sort of refereeing I think we may have a chance of winning the league. | Shropshire |
| 112 |
Juan | Kermode |
He was a biased disgrace and ruined the match. I know - I was there. He seems to think he is bigger than the game and loves to be seen to please the 'top' players like Gerrard who was also a disgrace who should be kicked out of the England team. | Isle of Man |
| 113 |
steve | cotts |
worst second half display from a referee i have seen in at least 10 years, could be questioned on at least 10 wrong decisions, if man utd had lost in this fashion he would be refereeing in the alliance league now | bolton |
| 114 |
neil | black |
well i hope you will sleep well in your liverpool shirt.maybe some bedtime reading will help you sleep like a refeering manual. somebody must check his
bookmakers account. you cheat | scunthorpe |
| 115 |
Phil | McNamara |
I'm sorry, it's not sour grapes, I just don't know how someone can be THAT bad and not be taking a bung! | St Helens, Merseyside |
| 116 |
Iama | Bitterbluenose |
| Liverpool. |
| 117 |
mark | allin |
| |
| 118 |
stephen | matthews |
This Man is a disgrace, weak willed painfully not up to standard!! | |
| 119 |
mark | roulston |
Either he is inept and does not know the laws of the game (should thus not be a Premier League referee) or something more sinister. | |
| 120 |
martin | allen |
most obviously biased refereeing i have ever had the misfortune to witness.a truely shocking display. | runcorn |
| 121 |
John | Gannaway |
Clattenburg is useless, even i know that | Carlisle |
| 122 |
stevie | gerrard |
Can we have you ref every week. | scouseland |
| 123 |
p | mcdivitt |
| |
| 124 |
Edward | Owens |
Worst refereeing decision re the last minute non-penalty i have ever witnessed, either complete incompetance or dare i say biased, either way at the very least he should not be allowed to referee a game containing ether of these teams or better still stri | Oldham |
| 125 |
Bing | Chyi |
Mark Clattenburg is the dark side of football!
Steven Gerrad is the hypocrite of all time!
Liverpool fans will never wank alone! | London |
| 126 |
Justin | Crook |
He should stick to making cakes. | Liverpool |
| 127 |
Daniel | Lim |
This guy is a disgrace to football | London |
| 128 |
Peter | Brown |
Clattenburg has to be banned for his disgraceful and biased performance, Rob Styles was banned for one mistake against the shite, so if the FA don't ban Clattenburg that makes them all corrupt and as bad as him. | London |
| 129 |
tom | hesketh |
totally inept performance, he should have his salary docked and paid to the everton supporters who he robbed of their money | st helens |
| 130 |
Albert | Yeong |
With such official, no wonder the BIG 4 remain up there. Such a disgrace!!! How can he even be qualify to officiate a BPL match? The Blues were robbed!!! | Singapore |
| 131 |
Mike | Hill |
How the 'big' four get preferential treatment is beyond me. Nothing will be down about this becaus we are Everton and not a Manchester United/Liverpool/Arsenal or Chelsea | West |
| 132 |
she | isablue |
I don't expect anything to be done by the FA as it is run by the biggest red of all but they really need to look at video replays and if a player such as Steven Gerrard can influence a referee then the game is fundamentally flawed | Merseyside |
| 133 |
Wayne | Mackney |
An absolutely disgraceful performance & the whole game suffered as a result. If you can't cope with big games and derby atmosphere's, go ref in the conference where your mistakes are just dismissed as "one of those things that happen in football" | Plymouth |
| 134 |
george | fulton |
absolute fucking disgraceful refereeing | middlewich |
| 135 |
Clive | Thomas |
I blame Kenwirght meself, like. | Above Everton |
| 136 |
Ben | Fitzsimmons |
| |
| 137 |
Gavin | Still |
Absolute disgrace. Favoured Liverpool and handed them a win. | Brighton |
| 138 |
Henrik | Nygren |
A total disgrace! I hope you didnŽt sleep well and stay at home Mark, otherwise iŽll come and get you. Do never enter the grass of Goodison once more! TWAT | Halmstad, Sweden |
| 139 |
Simon | Burtenshaw |
I am VERY happy to sign this petition!, Mr Clattenburg's refereeing yesterday was quite simply HORRENDOUS & he treated the RS with TOTAL IMPUNITY, in fact, he was a TOTAL disgrace, & the NO PENALTY for us when Carragher wrestled Lescott to the floor | Seaford, East Sussex |
| 140 |
jennifer | carvath |
3 points lost for everton due to the actions of one man mark clattenburg who in my opion fixed the game .Come on the FA explain this one | liverpool |
| 141 |
Brian | Hill |
Shameful | RSA |
| 142 |
MICK | GOODALL |
DISGRACEFUL PERFORMANCE HE STARTED OUT AS THE REF THEN DECIDED FERRARD BE A BETTER REF THEN HE HANDED OVER TO CARRAGAHER WHEN GERRARD WENT OFF DISGRACEFUL PERFORMANCE ALL ROUND AND CALLING HIM A CHEAT ISNT TOO STRONG | WORCESTER |
| 143 |
Conor | Waters |
I used to respect this referee, but all that changed yesterday. A true injustice occurred at goodison park, his blatant errors and frankly bias must not go unpunished... | Dundalk, Ireland. |
| 144 |
Jon | Manning |
Disgrace - Ruining the beautiful game. | liverpool |
| 145 |
james | griffiths |
i haver never seen such a biased game ever before, the kung fu yellow card was amazing | rhyl |
| 146 |
Henry | Daw |
| |
| 147 |
Eike | Baumann |
Out! | Germany |
| 148 |
Rory | Slingo |
This man is a disgrace to the profession and the entire sport, and so will the FA if they do not act. | Singapore |
| 149 |
Becky | Smith |
I was at the game and it was an absolute travesty, I know you often hear the phrase 'playing against 12 men' but this was a prime example of it. Bad decisions and obvious mistakes..this man should be in a position where he actually has no responsibility!! | Isle of Man |
| 150 |
mike | lewis |
how the fuck can he shake hands with gerrard when he got subbed,surely it all needs investigating.smells of match fixing | whitchurch |
| 151 |
Nicky | Wilson |
| |
| 152 |
Alan | Oates |
His performance was at best complete incompetence and at worst simply match fixing | Isle of Man |
| 153 |
Andrew | Morden |
A sadly myopic performance from Mr Clattenburg in the game he officated 20/10/07 (Everton vs. Liverpool). He made dreadful errors that influenced the outcome of the game. A precedent has been set regarding punishing refs -Rob Styles. Please take action | West Midlands |
| 154 |
John | Martin |
Mark Clattenburg showed favouritism today that was unjust. Decisions were made that altered the result because of his poor judgement and weak willed behaviour that allowed a Liverpool player to change his mind | Bootle |
| 155 |
Tony | Heslop |
Demotion to the coca cola and a fulsome apology and reassurance he doesn't referee everton again this season would be appropriate but the point needs to be hammered home about the G14 clubs receiving favourable treatment | liverpool |
| 156 |
gaz | mc |
the little shitbag listening to gerrard. and see the way he made an effort to shake gerrards hand when he got subbed aswell. gobshite | liverpool |
| 157 |
Stefan | Basiuk |
Always thought MC was one of the better refs, his performance on Sat was so biased it was bordering on insulting my intelligence ! | London |
| 158 |
Ruaraidh | Callinan |
Ive seen some bad refeering performances in my time, but the one from Clattenburg at Goodison was by far and away the worst, by some distance!! | Northampton |
| 159 |
Gary | Robinson |
TWAT | crewe |
| 160 |
jim | fitzsimons |
Lets hope this petition makes Keith Hackett stand by his words after the Rob Styles fiasco:- "Accountability exists and we expect referees to get big decisions correct."
Action must be taken now this precedent has been set. | bootle |
| 161 |
Ron | Cassidy |
I agree absolutely. There was no possible excuse or justification for the decisions you highlight above. Those decisions had a direct bearing on the destination of the 3 points.
They suspended Rob Styles; they should do the same at least for Clatenburg | Manchester |
| 162 |
Ian | Robb |
Just a disgrace...i work hard living doin wat i do and this guy has made mistakes that any normal working person would get sacked for.The FA must take action over Gerrard allowing him to change his mind..either that or he is on payroll at liverpool. | Sheffield |
| 163 |
Ladislav | Hegyi |
Ban Mark Clattenburg for life from refereeing in the Premier League !!! | Slovakia |
| 164 |
Joe | Hurst |
Simply an embarrassment to the profession on that display. | N Wales |
| 165 |
Mike | Mc:Loughlin |
I find his decision making incomrpehensible at worsy and baffling at best. How you can decide to gve a yellow card then once spoken to by a n opposing captain then give a red appeards corrupt. He then see 2 blatant nailed on penalty claims then choose.He
| St. Helens |
| 166 |
Sur | Jo |
Mark Clattenburg refusal to give Everton a penalty in the last minute of the game (when Lescott was fouled) is a serious abuse that needs to be investigated. | Michigan |
| 167 |
Simon | Darrow |
Utter disgrace | Birmingham |
| 168 |
Damien | McCabe |
What a joke this referee is. Everton didn't stand a chance with a ref like this one. What is happening to football? The game's under threat with refs that make such openly biased decisions. Where was his Liverpool shirt? | Salisbury |
| 169 |
Martin | Cutler |
No ref should be so easily influenced by players. Changing a yellow to a red because a player tells him to is absolutely shocking. The ref should be banned for the season! The player in question should also be banned. It's cheating! | USA |
| 170 |
John | Warham |
Clattenburg's performance was utterly inept and lamentable.
Officiating in England has a poor reputation but plumbed new depths with his refusal to send off Kuyt for a potentially career ending challenge and his inability to award a penalty for Everton | Liverpool |
| 171 |
robert | givnan |
I watched my first match at goodison park in 1957 and i have witnessed some terrible refereeing since then but this onesided biased joke of a referee is the worst i have ever seen. The FA if it is worth anything should ban this idiot. | Skelmersdale |
| 172 |
ALAN | PRINCE |
Inept, truly one-sided and hopelessly out of his depth. Games of this magnitude cannot be handed to this chap for a long time to come. | North Wales |
| 173 |
John | Hall |
If Mark Clattenburg was the most respected referee in the game at the moment, he certainly wasn't fair during the derby match, he was so bias even someone with vision problem would have notice what he was doing! | Cleveland |
| 174 |
Stephen | Hughes |
Sinister influence of 'big name' players over weak referees growing. 'Big four' clubs bullying their way to success. Gutless refereeing letting down the rest of us! | Leeds |
| 175 |
John | Cosgrove |
A terrible performance from the referre were I would say he made at least 5 major decisions that were wrong and worked against Everton. He should face a suspension and revise the rules of the game whilst he is banned.
A disgracful performance. BAN HIM! | Liverpool |
| 176 |
Dan | Wragg |
He is an idoit, and should be brought out and made to apologise in front of the Everton fans - we would have won if it wasn't for him, COYB | Holiday in Lanzarote |
| 177 |
anthony | maguire |
absolute disgrace totally biased towards liverpool not good enough for prem | holyhead |
| 178 |
Richard | Corley |
He is either corrupt or incompetent! No other employer would allow its employees to make so many mistakes and not be punished. | Chester |
| 179 |
andy | delaney |
coming away from the game i thought that maybe i was being over emotional when i blamed the ref for the defeat...now i realise he gave a performance at a level of incompetence that is even beyond mike riley | warrington |
| 180 |
Dave | O' |
Unbelieveble, yet again blatent cheating and nobody does anything about it, it looked like he had a bet on the outcome of the match, | Walton |
| 181 |
Barry | Challinor |
| Middleton,Manchester |
| 182 |
robbie | evans |
the prick should not be a ref! he is a disgrace | walton,liverpool |
| 183 |
Paul | O'Hanlon |
Spoilt the game completely with a weak and biased performance. A lifetime ban would be harsh and unrealistic, a one months ban, along with a public apology and phone call to Moyes a la Rob Styles after the Liverpool/Chelsea game? | Liverpool |
| 184 |
Peter | Keating |
He was a disgrace and clearly infulenced by the Liverpool players | London |
| 185 |
Tim | Muzio |
Mr Clattenburg should be dealt with the same punishment he inflicted on the Everton players by the FA A three match ban and put on a training course and 3 months in the championship. | Dublin |
| 186 |
Mike | Williams |
Recently referee Rob Styles was banned for incorrectly awarding Chelsea a penalty against Liverpool.
In yesterday's derby Clattenburg made at least THREE, possibly FOUR or FIVE mistakes, all in favour of Liverpool.
Will Mr Clattenberg be treated ac | Amsterdam |
| 187 |
Kenny | Dalglish |
Disgraceful refereeing but at least the best team won. | Location, Location |
| 188 |
Brett | Thomas |
An utter disgrace, and I am not even an Everton supporter. | London |
| 189 |
John | Kelly |
Mark Clattenburg = Bent Bastard | Wirral |
| 190 |
John | Carlson |
Just so bad it was untrue.
His positioning was perfect.. how can you not give that penalty?
It seems to me ref's onyl give pen's if your about to shoot.. when infact if its a foul in the box its a pen.
Bastards. | Liverpool, England |
| 191 |
wayne | moore |
an absolute disgrace should never be allowed to ref again, hope you die you cheat | Liverpool |
| 192 |
Andrew | Russell |
| Liverpool |
| 193 |
david | lee |
If i performed this badly at my job i would be seriously reprimanded and may even be soon out of work!!
The FA need to investigate further. | Charnock Richard |
| 194 |
Andrew | Bankes |
His performance in the Merseyside derby was a disgrace. | Manchester |
| 195 |
andy | norbury |
an absolute disgrace, should not be allowed to referee important games | ruthin |
| 196 |
jon | summer |
a discrace if it had been the other way round they'd have wanted him beheaded. Cheat corrupt bunge backhander call it what you will but it wasn't fair what happened to everton their fans must be outraged | burnley |
| 197 |
helen | nelson |
Mr Clattenburg's performance on Saturday was an absolute disgrace.
I was not aware that referees take orders from players or that they ignore blatant penalties. Maybe it should be explained to Mr Clattenburg that these decisions are not acceptable!! | Liverpool |
| 198 |
Scott | Hazell |
Liverpool's best signing this season | Coventry |
| 199 |
Tom | Dooley |
| Chester |
| 200 |
stu | tagg |
For a premier league official to allow a player to influence his decision to change a card from yellow to red is truly astounding , and shows that Clattenburg should not be in the game , let alone the top and fastest league in the world . | Liverpool |
